Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies

The pacifier is nothing else but a surrogate of the mother’s breast. For newborn and infants, sucking satisfies a basic need, that of nutrition, but this operation also allows them to establish a direct contact with the mother. For this reason, a pacifier that recalls the mother’s nipple can be beneficial for a small baby.

On the other hand, a pacifier also offers psychological support to the little ones, fighting against the feeling of loneliness, relaxing them and giving them a sensation of comfort, protection and numbness.

On the market, there are available many models of pacifiers, each with different characteristics. But if it’s easy to choose a pacifier for an artificially fed baby, when it comes to breastfed babies most mothers face the dilemma of finding the right pacifier.

To help you with the decision, we put up this guide that will explain why and how to choose the best pacifier for breastfed babies. We also reviewed five popular pacifiers and decided which is the best pacifier for breastfed babies available on the market.

How to Use the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies

The biggest dilemma for the mothers who decided to breastfeed their babies is whether the pacifier will interfere with the breastfeeding.

Since every baby is different, there is no universal answer to this question. However, the specialists believe that you shouldn’t use a pacifier in the first four to six weeks of the baby’s life. In this way, the baby will have the time to get used to the breastfeeding technique and you will avoid that the pacifier will interfere with the child’s preference for the breast.

Once the baby acquired the right feeding technique, you can introduce him to a pacifier. However, you should pay a lot of attention to the pacifier’s material and make sure you purchase a model suitable for your child’s age.

Pacifiers are typically made of silicone or rubber. Both materials are ideal for babies, but choosing one over the other should be a matter of age.

Silicone resists well to the sterilization process, and it is therefore indicated in the first months. You should use silicone pacifiers up to four or six months, as this material is more hygienic compared to rubber. However, it is not advisable to use silicone pacifiers for older babies, especially if they started to grow their teeth. They might tear the pacifier and choke with silicone pieces.

Rubber, on the other hand, is less recommended for the first months of life, because it can be contaminated more easily. However, rubber pacifiers are excellent for babies from six months onwards because they are more resistant and can be chewed without risks.

The nipple of the pacifier is equally important. On the market, there are two common models available.

  • Regular pacifiers: are simple, rounded, and usually look like the teat of the feeding bottle. These pacifiers don’t mimic the natural nipple very well and might interfere with the nipple preference.
  • Orthodontic pacifiers: these pacifiers are shaped to mimic the natural feeling of the breast, thus are more suitable for breastfed babies. In addition, these pacifiers don’t interfere with the natural oral development of the baby.
MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier

Knowing the models will help you choose best pacifiers.

Another important aspect is the shape of the pacifier. Commonly, two shapes are used.

Natursutten 2 Pack BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier
  • Round: used for both silicone and rubber pacifiers. These pacifiers are usually created in one piece and the soft material doesn’t create any particular problems during sleeping.
  • Butterfly shaped: these pacifiers are typically made from multiple parts, the butterfly typically being made of rigid plastic. This model is usually preferred for older babies, mainly because the pacifiers are decorated with funny motifs and are brightly colored. However, some manufacturers produce one piecebutterfly shaped pacifiers.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using a Pacifier

Using a pacifier can have various benefits both for your child’s health and for your comfort. Because a pacifier can reassure the child and calm him down, it might result a useful tool when trying to make him sleep.

Sucking can also relieve the pain in babies, so a pacifier might help reducing the symptoms of colic or other illnesses.

It was also scientifically proved that pacifiers reduce the risk of SIDS. It is not clear yet which mechanism is involved in reducing the sudden infant death syndrome, but the scientific community agrees on the fact that a pacifier helps in preventing this syndrome. It was also established that it is not indispensable that the pacifier stays inside the baby’s mouth for the whole night.

In fact, the sucking mechanism that helps the baby wake up when he goes in apnea persists in time. For this reason, you don’t have to put the pacifier back into the baby’s mouth if it is dropped while sleeping.

However, using a pacifier also has some disadvantages. Here they are:

  • ​The prolonged use of the pacifier is linked to the middle year infection in babies. This generally happens in cases of poor hygiene, so keeping the pacifier clean at all times is a must.
  • ​The pacifier use was also associated with a higher risk of stomach infections or other disorders such as vomiting and diarrhea.
  • If you use a pacifier with an unsuitable teat, it might interfere with the normal development of the baby’s oral cavity.
  • Lastly, the use of a pacifier can interfere with the breastfeeding, especially if it is used daily. The baby might develop a preference for the pacifier, which will lead to an incorrect attachment to the mother’s nipple. This can cause the reduction of the milk production earlier than normal. The World Health Organization even discourages the use of a pacifier for this precise reason.

Pacifiers Dos and Don’ts

If you decide to use a pacifier for your breastfed baby, here is a list of what you should and shouldn’t do:

  • Choose an orthodontic pacifier.
  • Keep the pacifier as clean as possible and sterilize it as often as you would sterilize the teat of the feeding bottle.
  • Change the pacifier as soon as you notice any cracks, cuts or holes into it.
  • Don’t force your baby to accept the pacifier, and don’t ever put any sugar or honey on the pacifier to trick your baby to accept it.
  • Don’t use the pacifier when the baby is hungry.
  • Don’t clean the pacifier with your mouth.
  • Don’t tie the pacifier around the baby’s neck. He might suffocate.

How to Wean Your Baby

Once your baby is old enough, you will probably want to make him give up on the pacifier. The task is not simple, but with a little patience, you should convince him that the pacifier is no longer needed. Here is how to do it:

  • Start gradually, trying to limit the use of the pacifiers as much as possible.
  • Try to make an agreement with your child about the suitable moments when he should use the pacifier, such as before the bedtime.
  • Distract the child as much as possible with fun games. The best thing to do if you want to make him forget about the pacifier is to focus his attention on other objects or things to do.
  • Try to store the pacifier in inaccessible drawers or in other places where the child can’t see it. Only take it out in “critical” situations.

That being said, let’s see which are the best pacifiers for breastfed babies available on the market.

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

1. MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic

MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier

A nice and simple pacifier, made of BPA-free silicone and suitable for breastfed babies is this MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier. The pacifier was developed by the pediatric dentists to provide maximum comfort for babies up to six months old. Boasting a symmetrical nipple, you will not have to worry about the position in which you give the pacifier to the baby.

To avoid nipple confusion, the nipple of the pacifier mimics very well the natural nipple of the mother. The purchase package includes two pacifiers and a carrying case that can also be used for easier sterilization. The manufacturer produces this pacifier in various colors, including unisex or gender dedicated models.

Things We Liked

  • Glows in the dark: a fabulous feature for a pacifier is the glow in the dark button. In this way, you will be able to spot the pacifier easily during the night without needing to turn on the light.
  • Curved shield: the curved shape of the pacifier’s shield allows it to sit comfortably on the baby’s face. The shield also presents many holes to allow the air to circulate.
  • Anti-slip nipple texture: the nipple is made of soft silicone that has an anti-slip texture.
  • Mimic the mother’s breast: to avoid pacifier preference, the nipple of the pacifier mimics very well the natural feeling of the mother’s breast.

Things We Didn't Like

  • You will have to expose the pacifier to a reasonable amount of bright light if you really want it to glow in the dark. The clear material, however, makes it hard to find in a lighted environment.

2. Philips AventSoothie Pacifier

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

A hospital-trusted pacifier that doesn’t create any nipple confusion is the Avent Soothie Pacifier from Philips. This pacifier is made of BPA-free soft silicone and is designed to adapt perfectly to the mouth of the babies. It is made in one piece and reduces considerably the risk of suffocation.Philips manufactures its Soothie pacifier in various dimensions, suitable from the first days of life until weaning. The hospital-grade silicone used for the production of this pacifier is durable and can be sterilized by various methods, including in the dishwasher.

Things We Liked

  • Wide color selection: this pacifier comes in six different colors, so you will be able to choose the one more suitable for your baby.
  • Taste and odor free: the hospital-grade silicone used for this pacifier is taste and odor free in addition to being approved by the pediatricians.
  • Supports the oral development: the unique shape of the nipple fits comfortably into the mouths of the newborn and small babies, not interfering with the normal oral development.
  • Resistant: the pacifier is made of strong silicone and doesn’t become sticky or discolored with the passage of the time.
  • Thing 2: bla bla bla

Things We Didn't Like

  • Especially for newborn and infants, the round shape of the pacifier might be too large and could cover the nose of the baby. This could cause respiratory problems.

3. BabyHuggle 4 in 1 Plush Monkey Pacifier

BabyHuggle 4 in 1 Plush Monkey Pacifier

One of the most versatile pacifiers available on the market, the Baby Huggle combo includes a BPA-free orthodontic silicone pacifier and a cute plush toy. The included pacifier is great for babies of six months or less, but you can simply replace it with a suitable pacifier once the baby is older. In this way, your baby will still be able to keep his best friend with him while using a suitable pacifier.

Compared to the other toy pacifiers, this one allows you to remove the pacifier, which is great especially for a proper sterilization. In addition, the plush toy is equipped with a durable clip holder and with a squeezable sound mechanism.

Things We Liked

  • Various models: in addition to the monkey model, you will be able to choose from a selection of other animals.
  • 100% safe pacifier: the pacifier is made of BPA-free silicone, is orthodontic and doesn’t create nipple confusion in newborn and small babies.
  • Removable pacifier: if your baby doesn’t accept the pacifier or when he is older, you can simply replace the included pacifier with another one.
  • Convenient clip holder: the toy is equipped with a convenient clip holder. You can attach the pacifier to the baby’s clothes or to the car seat or stroller, for more hygienic storage while on-the-go.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Even if the manufacturer advertises the clip holder as being childproof, it can actually be removed very easily by the babies and represents a choking hazard.

4. BabyStache Kissable Baby Pacifier

BabyStache Kissable Baby Pacifier

A cute and funny pacifier made of high-quality BPA-free silicone is this BabyStache Kissable Baby Pacifier. This adorable pacifier is orthodontic and shouldn’t cause nipple confusion in breastfed babies. The pacifier is suitable for newborn, infants and toddlers and promotes the healthy oral development of the baby.

The pacifier comes with a storage box that can also be used for sterilizing the pacifier. The shield presents small holes throughout its surface, designed to let the baby’s skin breathe.

Things We Liked

  • Funny design: this pacifier will not only keep your baby quiet and calm, but you will also have fun looking at this funny pacifier.
  • Suitable as baby shower gift: if you want to make an original yet useful baby shower gift, this pacifier might be the right choice.
  • Suitable for all ages: this pacifier is suitable for babies of all ages, since birth until weaning.
  • Neutral design: the pacifier is suitable for both girls and boys, having a neutral design.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Some parents complained about the weight of the pacifier, while others consider that the decorative part is made of cheap materials.

5. Natursutten 2 Pack BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier

Natursutten 2 Pack BPA Free Natural Rubber Pacifier

With a retro design, these pacifiers might remind you the times when you were a baby. However, these Natursutten pacifiers are made of 100% natural rubber, are orthodontic and shouldn’t lead to nipple confusion. These one-piece pacifiers are hygienic and don’t present any hazards for your baby.

The manufacturer produce these pacifiers for all age groups, so you should only be careful to replace the old pacifier with a new one as the baby grows. The pacifiers are manufactured in Italy by a family business, contain no harmful chemicals and correspond to the European safety requirements that are similar to the American ones.

Things We Liked

  • Made by a family-run business: these pacifiers are manufactured under the careful surveillance of a family and are made of natural rubber.
  • Patented design: these one-piece pacifiers boast a patented design that presents no joints, holes or cracks where bacteria can grow.
  • Easy to sterilize and maintain: the Natursutten pacifiers can be easily sterilized in boiling water and should be cleaned daily with warm water and mild soap.
  • Butterfly shaped: the butterfly shaped pacifiers will not cover the baby’s nose, so there is no risk of suffocation.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Some users reported size differences between the nipples of the pacifiers bought for the same age group. This might be caused by the artisanal manufacture, but it still represents a problem for the parents.

Conclusion and Final Pick

In our opinion, the best pacifier for breastfed babies is the MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Pacifier.We like this pacifier because it’s orthodontic, made of BPA-free silicone and doesn’t create nipple confusion for breastfed babies.The butterfly design and the curved shape of the shield ensures a good adherence to the baby’s face and it presents no hazards of suffocation. In addition, the shield allows the air’s circulation.The glow in the dark feature is another big plus for this great pacifier. The pacifier is manufactured for all age groups and it is probably the best pacifier for breastfed babies available on the market.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments